What we do
Calculators Legal guide Legal glossary Frequently asked questions About us Contact

Reinstatement Claims: Conditions, Time Limits and Outcomes

Who can bring one, how the one-month period runs, is mediation mandatory, and what happens if you win?

Reinstatement Claims: Conditions, Time Limits and Outcomes — Hasan Hüseyin Uzun Law Office legal guide

In short: Reinstatement is the route open to an employee within job security protection who faces an invalid termination. This guide covers the conditions, the one-month period that extinguishes the right entirely if missed, and the mediation stage.

A reinstatement claim is the route open to an employee within the scope of job security against a termination that does not rest on a valid reason. Its purpose is not merely to obtain compensation but to have the termination declared invalid. The most critical aspect of a reinstatement claim is not legal but calendrical: if the deadline is missed, the right disappears entirely and the merits of the file are never examined.

Who can bring a reinstatement claim? #

Four conditions must be met together:

  • At least thirty employees at the workplace. The number covers the employees at all of the employer’s workplaces in the same branch of activity; it is the whole, not the number at a single branch, that counts.
  • At least six months of service by the employee. That condition does not apply to underground work. Periods at different workplaces of the same employer are aggregated.
  • Working under an open-ended employment contract. Fixed-term contracts are as a rule outside the scope; but where a contract has been made fixed-term without an objective reason, it is treated as open-ended from the outset.
  • Not being a representative of the employer. Managers who direct and administer the undertaking as a whole, and those with the power to hire and dismiss, are outside the scope.

Is the termination valid? #

When dismissing an employee within the scope of job security, the employer must state the reason for the termination in writing and clearly. Failing to give a reason, or changing it afterwards, invalidates the termination on its own. A valid reason may arise from the employee’s capability or conduct or from the requirements of the undertaking. Where poor performance is alleged, measurable targets must have been notified in advance and the employee’s explanation taken. In a termination for economic reasons, the employer must establish the downsizing with concrete data and must have applied termination as a last resort.

In terminations based on conduct, if no explanation was taken from the employee the termination is invalid. That is the procedural defect which, on its own, determines the outcome in a significant proportion of files.

The one-month period: the most critical point #

Applying to a mediator within one month of service of the notice of termination is compulsory. That is a preclusive period: it does not stop, it is not interrupted, and the court takes it into account of its own motion. A single day’s delay means the claim is dismissed without the merits being reached. Where the notice was served by hand, the date is the date of signature on the record; where it was sent by post, it is the date of receipt.

If no agreement is reached at the mediation meeting, a claim must be brought in the labour court within two weeks of the date the final record was drawn up. That second period is preclusive too. If you want to check the periods for your own file, you can use our time limit and limitation checker.

The effect of agreement at mediation #

If agreement is reached at the mediation stage, whether the employee will be taken back and the sum to be paid must be written expressly in the record. The agreement document has the character of a judgment; no claim can afterwards be brought on the same subject. That is why attending the meeting with a calculated schedule of claims is decisive. To see your severance and notice items in advance you can use our severance and notice pay calculator, and for overtime and weekly rest claims our employee claims calculator.

Who bears the burden of proof? #

In a reinstatement claim the burden of proving that the termination rested on a valid reason lies with the employer. If the employee alleges that the termination rested on some other reason (trade union activity, a complaint, pregnancy), they must prove that themselves. That allocation is the structural element which makes reinstatement files relatively strong for employees.

What happens if the claim succeeds? #

If the reinstatement claim is upheld and the termination declared invalid, two separate claims arise:

  1. Pay for the period out of work: up to four months of pay and other entitlements for the period during which the employee was not employed. It arises when the judgment becomes final.
  2. Compensation for not being taken back: paid if the employer does not take the employee back; the court sets it at between four and eight months’ pay. Files with long service and a weak reason for termination approach the upper limit.

The employee must apply to the employer within ten working days of service of the final judgment, stating that they wish to return to work. Without that application the termination becomes valid and neither item can be claimed. The employer must take the employee back within one month of the application.

The relationship with severance pay #

A reinstatement judgment does not invalidate severance and notice pay already made; if the employee is taken back, those amounts are set off. If they are not taken back, the date of termination is treated as the date on which they were not taken back, severance is recalculated by reference to that date and the difference is paid. For the details of the calculation see our severance pay guide.

If you are outside the scope of job security #

An employee who does not meet the thirty-employee or six-month conditions cannot bring a reinstatement claim; but they are not without protection. The route that arises here is compensation for bad faith. If it is proved that the right of termination was abused — that the employee was dismissed for making a complaint, giving evidence or pursuing their rights, for instance — compensation of three times the pay for the notice period is awarded. That compensation is claimed in addition to payment in lieu of notice.

Furthermore, if the termination breaches the prohibition of discrimination — where it was based on language, race, sex, disability, political opinion, religion or trade union activity — compensation for discrimination can be claimed, and that compensation is available to employees within the scope of reinstatement too. In a termination for trade union reasons the compensation cannot be less than one year of the employee’s pay.

Which claims arise in that case and the steps to take in the first week after dismissal can be found in our guide to employee rights on dismissal.

What documents should be prepared? #

  • The original notice of termination or the record of its service — the date is decisive here
  • The employment contract, the job description and any performance targets
  • Payslips for the last three months and bank records of pay
  • The social security service record and the notification of leaving employment
  • The letter requesting an explanation and the explanation given
  • Correspondence and e-mails before the termination, and witness details

Having these documents gathered before the mediation meeting directly affects both the prospect of agreement and the amount agreed.

Length of proceedings and strategy #

In the labour courts, reinstatement files are by their nature given priority; the first-instance stage mostly takes six to fourteen months. Since the appellate review is final, the route of cassation is closed and the total period is short compared with other employment claims. In practice some employees aim not at returning to work but at the compensation for not being taken back; that is a legitimate choice, but the application to return to work must still be made once the judgment is final.

For the subject as a whole, see our employment and social security law page.

The difference between valid termination and termination for just cause #

What is argued in a reinstatement claim is whether the termination was valid; that is different from, and a lower threshold than, termination for just cause. Termination for just cause gives the right to terminate immediately in the serious situations set out in article 25 of the Labour Act (conduct destroying the relationship of trust, absenteeism, endangering occupational safety) and can also extinguish severance pay.

Valid termination, by contrast, arises from the employee’s incapability, their conduct or the requirements of the undertaking; the notice period must be observed and severance and notice pay must be made. If the employer based the termination on just cause but the court does not find it justified and treats it as valid instead, reinstatement is refused but severance and notice pay may be awarded.

Review of the business decision #

An employer may terminate on grounds of economic difficulty or restructuring; the court does not review the merits of that business decision. What it does review is whether the decision was applied consistently.

Two criteria are decisive: termination as a last resort (whether another position was offered to the employee, whether overtime was eliminated) and consistency (whether new employees were hired in the same period to do the same work). A new recruitment immediately following a dismissal invalidates the termination in most files.

Av. Hasan Hüseyin Uzun
Av. Hasan Hüseyin Uzun
Avukat · Hasan Hüseyin Uzun Avukatlık Bürosu

Frequently asked on this subject

4 questions
If I bring a reinstatement claim, must I return my severance pay?
No. You are not asked to return severance pay or payment in lieu of notice already received. If you are taken back, those amounts are set off; if you are not, the date of termination changes, severance is recalculated and any difference is paid to you.
How is the thirty-employee threshold calculated?
The number is found by adding together the employees at all of the employer’s workplaces in the same branch of activity on the date of termination. Subcontractor employees are as a rule counted as belonging to their own employer. Simulated arrangements made to bring the number below thirty are disregarded by the court.
I work on a fixed-term contract — can I seek reinstatement?
As a rule, no. But if there is no objective reason requiring the contract to be fixed-term, it is treated as open-ended from the outset and, where the other conditions are met, reinstatement can be sought. This comes up frequently with chains of renewed contracts.
I resigned — can I bring a reinstatement claim?
As a rule, no; reinstatement is a remedy against an invalid termination. But if it is proved that the resignation was signed under pressure, or that a contract in fact ended by the employer was presented as a resignation, the act is characterised as a termination and, if the application was made in time, the case can be heard.

This article is for general information; it is not legal advice on your own case. Time limits and their application can vary with the particulars of a file. Let us talk your situation through.

All our services in Labour and Social Security Law Severance pay and notice pay, reinstatement, overtime and wage claims, mobbing, workplace accidents…

Contact

You can reach the office by phone, by email or through the appointment form. Meetings take place at the office in Bakırköy or by video.

WhatsApp Call