What we do
Calculators Legal guide Legal glossary Frequently asked questions About us Contact

Construction Contract in Return for Flats and Delay Compensation

Form requirement, default, delay and rescission in construction against a land share.

Construction contract in return for flats and delay compensation — Hasan Hüseyin Uzun Law Office legal guide

In short: A construction contract in return for flats is one of the contracts that gives rise to the most disputes between landowner and contractor. This guide explains the form requirement, the landowner's rights on the contractor's delay, and delay compensation.

A construction contract in return for flats (construction against a land share) rests on the landowner transferring the land to the contractor and receiving in return a share of the independent units to be built. In practice it is one of the contract types giving rise to the most, and the gravest, disputes; because the parties' obligations are spread over a long time, the project may change, and delay directly affects everyone's interests. For this reason setting the contract up correctly from the start is far more important than the actions brought later.

Form requirement: why must it be made before a notary? #

Because this contract contains an obligation to transfer immovable ownership, it must be made in official form, that is, drawn up before a notary. An ordinary written text or an oral agreement is, as a rule, invalid; this invalidity may allow the parties to withdraw from the contract easily later. However, in cases where the obligations have been performed to a significant extent — for example where most of the construction is complete — asserting invalidity may be contrary to the rule of good faith. Annotating the contract and the landowner's claim on the title register secures this right against third parties who later acquire the property, and prevents most grievances at the outset.

Legal basis: The requirement that contracts containing an undertaking to sell immovable property be made in official form arises from Article 706 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 and Article 237 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098.

If the contractor delays the construction #

The delivery date, and often the rough/fine construction stages, are set in the contract. If the contractor does not deliver on the agreed date, they fall into default and the landowner has more than one option:

  • Performance in kind and delay compensation: Requiring the construction to be completed while claiming, as delay compensation, the rental income lost through the late delivery.
  • Rescission of the contract: If the delay is grave and no result is obtained despite time being granted, ending the contract and requiring transfer of the land and compensation for the loss suffered.
  • Incomplete and defective work: Even if the building is delivered, resorting to the provisions on defects for work that is contrary to the project, incomplete or faulty, and requiring a reduction in price or repair.

If the unit delivered has defects such as faulty water or heat insulation or workmanship errors, the optional rights of a consumer may also be exercised; for the time limits and the body to apply to see our article on defective goods and the consumer arbitration committee.

How is delay compensation calculated? #

The most common measure of delay compensation is the comparable rent that the independent units the landowner should have received under the contract could have earned during the period of delay. The period is that between the agreed delivery date and actual delivery (or the calculation date in the action). This value is usually determined by expert examination, taking the rent level of similar properties in the area as the basis. If a penalty clause was also agreed in the contract, that sum too can be claimed where the conditions are met. For the calculation to be made soundly, the agreed delivery date and the actual delay must be shown by documents.

If the contractor abandons the work #

If the contractor leaves the construction half-finished, abandons the site or goes bankrupt, the landowner may, where the conditions are met, terminate the contract and, setting off the value of the work done, take back the land, or require the work to be completed. The most common problem at this stage is that part of the land share has been transferred to the contractor or to third parties to whom they have sold flats; in that case an action for annulment of title and re-registration comes into play, and the position of good-faith third parties is assessed separately. You may consult our construction and zoning law page for such disputes.

Points to watch when making the contract #

Most disputes arise from details overlooked at the contract stage. In a sound construction contract in return for flats the following should be regulated clearly:

What the contract must contain #

  • A firm delivery date and penalty clause: The daily or monthly penalty to apply on delay should be set from the start.
  • Sharing table: Which independent unit will go to whom should be written clearly, with floor and facade information.
  • Technical specification: The material and workmanship quality should be fixed by an attached specification; vague terms such as "or similar" should be avoided.
  • Title transfer timetable: The construction stage at which the land share will be transferred should be tied in stages; transferring it all at the start can be risky.
  • Annotation: Annotation of the contract on the title register should not be omitted.

When these details are put in writing, proof is greatly eased in the event of delay or dispute, and the parties' rights are secured. Moreover, when every stage of the construction is recorded with photographs and minutes, proof becomes far easier in any later dispute over incomplete or defective work, and trust between the parties is preserved.

This content is for general information only; it does not replace legal advice on a specific matter. Conditions and periods may change according to the legislation in force.

The landowner’s security: land registry annotation and mortgage #

Drawing the contract up before a notary is not enough on its own; the landowner’s real security is having the right annotated on the land register. If a construction contract in return for flats containing an undertaking to sell is annotated on the land register, the landowner’s personal right becomes enforceable against third parties as well for five years. Where transfers are made without the annotation, asserting a right against a third party who acquired the property in good faith becomes very difficult.

The staged transfer model #

The security method most preferred in practice is transferring the land share not all at once but in stages according to the level of construction: a certain proportion when the shell is finished, a proportion when the finishing work is completed, and the remaining proportion when the occupancy permit is obtained. The whole plot is then not lost if the contractor abandons the work.

Mortgage and security note #

Establishing a mortgage in the landowner’s favour over the transferred land share ties the claim to the property if the contractor fails to perform. Taking a security note equal to the contractual penalty is also common. The possibility of the contractor mortgaging the land share to a bank and drawing a loan should be expressly restricted in the contract.

Actions arising from the contract and limitation #

When a dispute arises, the actions that may be brought and their time limits are as follows:

ActionFor whatTime limit
Delay (loss of rent) compensationLoss suffered because delivery was lateContractual claim: 10 years
Contractual penalty claimThe daily or monthly penalty agreed in the contract10 years
Annulment of title and registrationRecovery of the share transferred10 years if the contract has been terminated
Termination of the contract and return of the plotWork left unfinished, serious default10 years
Defective workmanship (contract for work)Errors of workmanship and materials5 years from delivery; 20 years in cases of gross fault

In defective workmanship the period runs from the date of delivery; the date and content of the delivery record are therefore decisive. Signing a general statement in the record such as “received complete and free of defects” weakens later claims. For hidden defects the period is assessed from the date the defect came to light.

The difference between floor easement, occupancy permit and urban transformation #

Three separate stages are frequently confused in construction in return for flats:

  • Floor easement: A right established over independent units in a building not yet completed. The land share is usually transferred at this stage; the unit does not yet physically exist.
  • Occupancy permit: The document showing that the building has been completed in accordance with the project. Without it, condominium ownership cannot be established and utility subscriptions do not become permanent.
  • Condominium ownership: Established after the occupancy permit; each unit is given its own title deed. The contractor’s obligation to obtain the occupancy permit should be written expressly into the contract.

If the building has been designated a risky structure under Law No. 6306, the process runs differently: special provisions on the decision quorum, rent assistance and the sale of the land share apply. In that case the contract to be signed must be assessed together with the urban transformation legislation. For the general framework of title disputes see our article on the action for annulment of title and registration.

Av. Hasan Hüseyin Uzun
Av. Hasan Hüseyin Uzun
Avukat · Hasan Hüseyin Uzun Avukatlık Bürosu

Frequently asked on this subject

4 questions
Must a construction contract in return for flats be made before a notary?
Yes. Because the contract contains an obligation to transfer immovable property, it must be made in official form, drawn up before a notary. An ordinary written or oral agreement is as a rule invalid. Annotating the contract on the title register protects the landowner's right against third parties.
What can I claim if the contractor delivers the building late?
You may require completion of the construction and claim, as delay compensation, the rental income lost through late delivery; if the delay is grave you may rescind the contract. The provisions on defects can also be invoked for incomplete and defective work.
How is delay compensation calculated?
The most common measure is the comparable rent the independent units due to be received could have earned during the delay. The period is that between the contractual delivery date and actual delivery. If there is a penalty clause in the contract it can be claimed additionally.
If the contractor abandons the construction, can I take my land back?
If the contractor abandons the work or goes bankrupt, you may terminate the contract and, setting off the value of the work done, take your land back, or require completion. If the title has been transferred, an action for annulment of title and re-registration comes into play.

This article is for general information; it is not legal advice on your own case. Time limits and their application can vary with the particulars of a file. Let us talk your situation through.

All our services in Construction and Zoning Law Construction contracts in exchange for flats, contractor delay and delay compensation, incomplete…

Contact

You can reach the office by phone, by email or through the appointment form. Meetings take place at the office in Bakırköy or by video.

WhatsApp Call