Cheques, promissory notes and bills of exchange are negotiable instruments. In pursuing claims based on those documents, a route is followed that differs from an ordinary debt and is far faster. That route, used for recovering cheque and promissory note debts, is called the attachment route specific to negotiable instruments; an objection by the debtor does not stop the proceedings automatically.
Is the instrument valid? Check that first #
Proceedings on a negotiable instrument can only be brought on a valid instrument. The elements that must appear in a promissory note are:
- The words promissory note or note payable to order — they must appear in the text of the instrument
- An unconditional promise to pay a definite sum
- To whom, or to whose order, it is to be paid
- The date and place of issue
- The signature of the issuer
If no maturity date is written, the instrument is treated as payable on sight; that does not invalidate it. But the absence of the date of issue or of the issuer’s signature takes the document out of the category of negotiable instruments. In that case the debt is pursued through the general attachment route like an ordinary debt. Where a blank note is filled in afterwards, an allegation of completion contrary to the agreement arises, and proving it falls to the person who signed the note.
How do the proceedings begin? #
The creditor submits the original of the instrument to the enforcement office and requests proceedings. The office sends the debtor a payment order. The periods allowed to the debtor in the payment order are:
- Ten days to pay the debt
- Five days to apply to the enforcement court to object to the signature or to the debt
- Ten days to make a declaration of assets if no objection is made and the debt is not paid (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law art. 168/6)
The five-day objection: the most critical period #
An objection in proceedings on a negotiable instrument differs from the general attachment route in two respects. First, the period is not seven days but five. Second, the objection is made not to the enforcement office but to the enforcement court, and on its own it does not stop steps in the proceedings other than a sale. For the proceedings to stop, an order temporarily suspending the proceedings must additionally be obtained from the enforcement court; the court may make such an order on an objection to the debt where a document shows that the debt was paid or deferred, or where limitation appears from the instrument, and on an objection to the signature where it considers the objection serious (Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law arts. 169/a, 170).
If the signature is being objected to, that must be stated separately and expressly in the application; a general objection does not cover the signature. The signature is examined by an expert. If the proceedings were temporarily suspended and the objection is then dismissed, compensation of not less than twenty per cent of the claim being pursued is awarded against the debtor; unfounded objections therefore carry an extra cost.
For the general attachment route and the periods for objecting, see our guide to objecting to enforcement proceedings, and for checking time limits our time limit and limitation checker.
Limitation periods #
Limitation periods for negotiable instruments are short, and missing them causes the claim to lose its character as a negotiable instrument claim:
- For a promissory note: three years against the issuer from maturity
- For a cheque: three years from the end of the period for presentation
- Between endorsers: six months from the date of payment
An instrument that has become time-barred does not become entirely worthless; a claim can be brought under the general provisions on the underlying relationship, that is the debt that gave rise to the instrument. But the burden of proof becomes heavier in that claim: the creditor has separately to establish the source of the debt.
The period for presenting a cheque #
A cheque is payable on sight. The periods for presentation vary with the place of issue and the place of payment: ten days in the same place, one month in different places, and one to three months depending on the country where they are in different countries. Where a cheque is not presented in time, the right to complain of a dishonoured cheque falls away and no recourse can be had against the endorsers.
A dishonoured cheque: a judicial, not an administrative, consequence #
Where a cheque is dishonoured, the holder can lodge a complaint. On that complaint the enforcement criminal court imposes a judicial fine equal to the amount of the cheque, and a ban on issuing cheques and opening cheque accounts is also applied. If the judicial fine is not paid it is converted directly into imprisonment.
The period for complaint is three months from the date on which the cheque was marked as dishonoured, and it is subject to a one-year period in any event. Once the whole debt is paid, the penalty falls away and the ban is lifted.
The liability of guarantors and endorsers #
Those who give an aval (a guarantee on a negotiable instrument) or who endorse it are liable jointly and severally with the principal debtor. The creditor can direct the whole of the debt to whichever of them they choose; there is no obligation to approach the principal debtor first. That possibility is often overlooked in the process of recovering cheque and promissory note debts: where the principal debtor has no assets, recovery from a company standing as an endorser may be possible.
For recourse to be had against endorsers and avalists, the instrument must have been presented in time and, where required, a protest must have been drawn up. A protest is the establishment of non-payment through a notary. If the instrument bears the words without protest, that step is unnecessary; in practice most instruments carry that clause.
If the debtor cannot pay #
The parties can always reach agreement after proceedings have begun. Payment by instalments can be arranged and entered in the record at the enforcement office; if an instalment is missed, the proceedings continue from where they left off. For the creditor that route often produces a faster result than attachment and sale, because the sale stage can take months and the sale price can fall below expectations.
Where the debtor is a company and it is thought to be in payment difficulty, proceedings by way of bankruptcy can also be considered. That route puts the creditor in the queue with the other creditors; it is therefore not a fast means of recovery on its own, but it does create pressure.
What steps are taken to recover? #
In recovering cheque and promissory note debts, the attachment stage follows once the payment order has become final. The most effective order in practice is: first bank accounts and claims held by third parties, then vehicle and land registry records, and then attachment at the business premises and the home. If no assets of the debtor can be found, a complaint to the enforcement criminal court for failure to make a declaration of assets — which can be required once the payment order is final — and an action for the annulment of dispositions alleging that the debtor has moved assets away both come into play.
For the subject as a whole, see our enforcement and bankruptcy law page.
For the form, content and cost of the notice to be sent before enforcement proceedings, see our guide to sending a formal notice.
If you have lost the instrument: the action for annulment #
A right on a negotiable instrument attaches not to the holder but to the instrument itself: without the instrument, no proceedings can be brought. For an instrument that has been lost, stolen or burnt, an action for annulment of the instrument is brought. The claim is heard by the commercial court of first instance for the place of payment and is a matter of non-contentious jurisdiction.
The court gives a period, by public notice, for anyone holding the instrument to come forward; if no one comes forward within that period, it orders the instrument annulled. The order for annulment takes the place of the instrument and the creditor can bring proceedings on it. Asking for a prohibition on payment to be imposed on the debtor while the claim runs prevents the instrument being paid to someone else.
The chain of endorsements and regular endorsement #
For a person taking an instrument to count as the holder of the right, they must have come to it through a regular chain of endorsements: each endorsement must have been made by the payee of the one before. A break in the chain opens the transferee’s title to argument and gives the debtor grounds for objection.
A blank endorsement (made by signature alone) is valid and shows the person holding the instrument to be the holder of the right; but that does not entirely close off objections about how the instrument came into their hands. Checking the endorsements on the reverse of the instrument for dates and signatures before starting proceedings forestalls objections that would otherwise arise later.

