What we do
Calculators Legal guide Legal glossary Frequently asked questions About us Contact

Malpractice (Medical Error) Compensation Claim Guide

The malpractice–complication distinction, informed consent, the competent court and the time limit.

Malpractice medical error compensation claim guide — Hasan Hüseyin Uzun Law Office legal guide

In short: A patient harmed by a faulty medical practice can claim material and moral compensation. This guide explains the distinction between malpractice and complication, informed consent and the correct court.

Not every adverse outcome after a medical intervention is legally an error. At the basis of a malpractice compensation claim lies the physician's or the health institution's breach of the duty of care — that is, a failure to observe the requirements of medical science and of the profession. For this reason the most critical distinction in these cases is whether the outcome is an unavoidable complication or a preventable error. Until this distinction is clear, neither liability nor compensation can be discussed correctly.

The difference between malpractice and complication #

A complication is an outcome that can arise even when everything is done according to the rules — medically foreseeable but unavoidable; if it was explained to the patient in advance and consent obtained, it does not, as a rule, give rise to liability. Malpractice, by contrast, arises from carelessness: wrong or late diagnosis, wrong drug or dose, an unindicated (unnecessary) intervention, wrong-side/organ surgery, a foreign object left in during surgery, breach of hygiene and sterilisation rules. This distinction is usually made through expert reports obtained from the Forensic Medicine Institute or universities, and largely determines the fate of the case. For this reason the complete gathering of the medical documents, the tests and the discharge summary is the first step of the process.

The physician is obliged to explain the intended procedure, the possible risks, the chance of success and the alternative treatments to the patient in language they can understand, and to obtain their consent. An intervention made without this informed consent duly fulfilled may give rise to liability in itself, even if the outcome is medically successful; for the patient's right to make an informed decision about their own body has been violated. On the settled understanding, consent is not merely the hurried signing of a printed form; it must rest on genuine, understandable and procedure-specific information. Different rules apply for emergency and unconscious patients.

Against whom, and in which court, is the action brought? #

The competent court and the defendant vary according to where the service was received; this is the point at which most errors are made:

  • Public (state/university) hospital: The action is brought not directly against the physician but against the administration, for a service fault, as a full remedy action, and is heard in the administrative court. An application to the administration beforehand is compulsory.
  • Private hospital or surgery: Since the patient is a consumer receiving a service for payment, a compensation action based on breach of contract and tort is brought in the ordinary courts, as a rule in the consumer court; mediation is mandatory before the action is filed (Law No. 6502, art. 73/A). The physician and the hospital may be held jointly liable.

Choosing the wrong court or the wrong defendant causes a serious loss of rights and time, since the case may be rejected on procedure years later.

In an action against a private hospital the competent venue is the district in which the hospital is located.

Limitation and what can be claimed #

Material losses such as treatment costs, incapacity and loss of earnings, and moral compensation for the pain and suffering endured, can be claimed; in permanent disability, carer costs, and in the event of death, the relatives' compensation for deprivation of support and funeral expenses come into play. In these cases the limitation periods vary according to whether the service was received in the public or the private sector and whether the claim rests on contract or on tort; for this reason time should not be lost and the periods should be calculated from the start. Because the relationship with a private physician or hospital is as a rule one of agency (mandate), the five-year limitation period (Code of Obligations art. 147/5) should be taken as the basis for contractual claims; in tort the period is two years from learning of the damage and ten years in any event. For public hospitals, an application must be made to the administration within one year of learning of the act and in any event within five years of it. On the process you may consult our health law and malpractice page; for a similar process of bodily harm, our article on work accident compensation.

Preparation before the action: which documents should be gathered? #

The strongest side of a malpractice case is a well-prepared medical file. Before the process begins the following documents should be gathered in full:

  • All medical records: the patient file, the discharge summary (epikriz), the operation note, test and imaging results, prescriptions.
  • Consent documents: the informed consent forms signed and any information letters.
  • Expense documents: invoices and reports showing subsequent treatment, medicine and care costs.
  • An independent opinion: where possible, an assessment obtained from another physician.

These documents are essential for the sound conduct of the expert examination on which the case will rest. Since the patient has a right of access to their own file, these records can be requested from the health institution before the action is brought. An incomplete file leads even a well-founded case to remain unproved.

This content is for general information only; it does not replace legal advice on a specific matter. Periods and conditions may change according to the legislation in force.

Proving fault: the expert and forensic medicine report #

The fate of a malpractice case is determined by the report on whether there was medical fault. Depending on the subject of the dispute, the court applies to a board of experts from the universities or to the Council of Forensic Medicine.

What does the report look at? #

  • Whether the treatment applied complied with the generally accepted standards of medical science.
  • Whether the duty of care was fulfilled at each of the stages of diagnosis, indication, choice of procedure and follow-up.
  • Whether the harm that arose was avoidable; that is, whether the outcome was a complication or a faulty application.
  • The scope of the informed consent and whether the patient’s having been informed was recorded.

Objecting to the report #

If the report is unfavourable, the objection submitted to the file must be concrete: which medical data was overlooked and which record it contradicts must be shown. Objections of a general nature produce no result. On a reasoned objection the court may request a supplementary report or appoint a new board. It is also possible to apply to the higher board of the Council of Forensic Medicine against its reports.

Criminal and disciplinary processes: they run separately from the compensation case #

A faulty medical application may give rise to three separate processes; they do not replace one another.

ProcessWhere to applyResult
CompensationConsumer court for a private hospital; administrative court for a public hospitalPecuniary and non-pecuniary damages
Criminal investigationPublic prosecutor’s office (negligent injury or causing death)A penalty for the doctor
DisciplinaryProvincial health directorate, the relevant medical chamber, or the institution if a public officialWarning, fine, temporary suspension from the profession

A finding of no fault in the criminal file does not by itself determine the outcome of the compensation case: the criterion of fault in criminal law and the duty of care in private law are not the same. The expert report obtained in the criminal file may, on the other hand, be used as evidence in the compensation case. The two processes are therefore planned together.

The exception to the rule that an action cannot be brought directly against a doctor who is a public official is the doctor’s personal fault falling outside their duties. This distinction is decisive for directing the action against the right party; an action brought against the wrong party causes loss of time.

The special position of private hospitals and aesthetic procedures #

Because a patient receiving services from a private hospital is regarded as a consumer, the relationship with the hospital is assessed under the Law on Consumer Protection and the case is heard in the consumer court. The hospital is also liable for the acts of the doctors working within it; the patient may sue the doctor and the hospital together.

For aesthetic procedures the legal classification changes. Aesthetic procedures without a therapeutic purpose are assessed as a contract for work; in that case the doctor is under an obligation not merely of care but of producing the agreed result. If the result is not achieved, the provisions on defective work apply and the patient’s burden of proof is markedly lightened. In procedures such as hair transplantation and nose or breast surgery this distinction affects the outcome directly.

In both cases the documents showing payment of the service fee, the contract made with the hospital and the undertakings given in promotional materials should be added to the file. In consumer disputes below the monetary threshold, the route of the consumer arbitration committee also comes into play.

Av. Hasan Hüseyin Uzun
Av. Hasan Hüseyin Uzun
Avukat · Hasan Hüseyin Uzun Avukatlık Bürosu

Frequently asked on this subject

4 questions
Is every unsuccessful operation malpractice?
No. Unavoidable outcomes that arise despite being done according to the rules are complications and do not require compensation. Malpractice arises from fault such as wrong diagnosis, wrong dose or a careless intervention. This distinction is usually determined by an expert report.
How is an action brought against a state hospital?
In public hospitals the action is brought not directly against the physician but against the administration, in the administrative court as a full remedy action, and an application to the administration is required beforehand. In private hospitals and surgeries a compensation action is brought, after mandatory mediation, as a rule in the consumer court. Choosing the right court is critical.
I signed the consent form; can I still bring an action?
Yes. Informed consent is not merely signing a printed form; it requires that the risks and alternatives are genuinely explained. If sufficient information was not given, or the duty of care was breached in the practice, liability may arise.
What losses can be claimed in a malpractice case?
Material losses such as treatment costs, incapacity and loss of earnings, and moral compensation for the suffering endured, can be claimed. In the event of death the relatives may claim compensation for deprivation of support. Since limitation runs, time should not be lost.

This article is for general information; it is not legal advice on your own case. Time limits and their application can vary with the particulars of a file. Let us talk your situation through.

All our services in Medical Law and Malpractice Compensation for harm caused by misdiagnosis and wrong treatment, surgery, childbirth, cosmetic and…

Contact

You can reach the office by phone, by email or through the appointment form. Meetings take place at the office in Bakırköy or by video.

WhatsApp Call