Deferral of the announcement of the judgment is the suspension, for a set period, of a judgment of conviction entered against a defendant without it being pronounced. If the probation period passes without incident, the case is discontinued and the defendant is treated as never having been convicted. This institution is one of the most frequently encountered, and most widely misunderstood, features of criminal procedure.
On what conditions does it apply? #
For deferral of the announcement of the judgment to be ordered, the following conditions must be met together:
- The sentence imposed must be imprisonment of two years or less, or a judicial fine. What counts is the amount finally imposed, not the type of sentence.
- The defendant must not previously have been convicted of an intentional offence. Convictions for offences of negligence are not a bar.
- The court must be satisfied that the defendant will not reoffend. Their personal characteristics and their attitude and conduct at the hearing are assessed.
- The damage caused by the offence must have been made good. This can be met by restitution in kind, by restoring the position that existed before the offence, or by compensation. If there is no damage, the condition does not apply. If the defendant cannot make good the damage at once, deferral may also be ordered on condition that the damage is paid off in full in monthly instalments during the probation period.
- The defendant’s acceptance is no longer required. For orders made on or after 1 June 2024 the court may order deferral without seeking the defendant’s acceptance; for orders made before that date the acceptance requirement still applies.
The law expressly prohibits deferral for offences of torture and torment and for offences committed by public officials in the course of their duties that may amount to ill-treatment within the meaning of article 17 of the Constitution.
How does the probation period work? #
The probation period is five years; for those who had not turned eighteen at the time of the offence it is three years. Within that period, for a term set by the court not exceeding one year, a probation measure may be applied to the defendant: attending a vocational training programme, being prohibited from going to certain places, or being required to attend certain places, for instance. Applying a measure is not compulsory; the court decides. The limitation period for prosecution is suspended during probation, and no further deferral may be ordered for an intentional offence while the probation period is running.
If no new intentional offence is committed during the probation period and any obligations are complied with, the judgment whose announcement was deferred is set aside and the case is discontinued. An offence committed through negligence does not breach the probation period.
The effect on the criminal record and on public employment #
A deferral order is not entered on the criminal record. Such orders are recorded in a separate system, and those records may be used only when requested by a public prosecutor, judge or court in connection with an investigation or prosecution. That is, it does not appear on an ordinary request for a criminal record certificate.
It can, however, be queried in the security vetting carried out on entry to public service and in certain professions. The misconception most often encountered in practice is the expectation that a deferral leaves no trace whatsoever in every circumstance. The order does not in law constitute a conviction of the person; but it may be taken into account in certain administrative processes.
Challenging a deferral order: appeal #
Deferral orders made on or after 1 June 2024 are challenged by way of appeal (istinaf). The appeal is lodged with the court that made the order within two weeks of service of the reasoned decision; the regional court of appeal reviews the order on procedure and on the merits. Where the order was made by a regional court of appeal or the Court of Cassation sitting at first instance, an appeal on points of law (cassation) lies. The rule in article 272/3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure on final, non-appealable decisions is reserved.
For deferral orders made before 1 June 2024 the old regime continues: they are challenged by objection, not appeal, and the defendant’s acceptance is required. In 2022 the Constitutional Court had held that the objection body confining its examination to formal conditions alone violated the freedom to seek justice; with the opening of the appeal route the order can now be reviewed on procedure and on the merits.
If a new offence is committed during probation #
Where a new intentional offence is committed or the probation obligations are breached, the court announces the judgment it had deferred. At that point the original judgment becomes enforceable and a conviction arises against the person. However, taking into account the situation of a defendant who could not fulfil the obligations, the court may order that part of the sentence, up to half, is not to be enforced, or, where the conditions are met, suspend the prison sentence or convert it into alternative sanctions, and enter a new judgment; it is not obliged to do so.
The judgment once announced, or newly entered, may be challenged by objection; the objection body examines only whether the conditions for announcing the judgment were met (Code of Criminal Procedure art. 231/11). Where a deferral order made before 1 June 2024 is announced, the old rules on remedies apply.
Accept the deferral or appeal? #
That is a choice which varies with the file. Once the deferral order becomes final the proceedings end, the risk of enforcement disappears and, if the period passes without incident, the case is discontinued. On the other hand it is not an acquittal; innocence can be established only by an acquittal. Since acceptance is no longer required after 1 June 2024, a defendant who believes the prospect of acquittal is strong can take the deferral order to appeal and ask for the conviction to be reviewed on procedure and on the merits; that may be the better choice in terms of record and compensation.
Moreover, any intentional offence committed during the five-year probation period revives the old file. That risk is often not weighed sufficiently when the decision is taken.
How many times can it be applied? #
The law sets no overall numerical limit; but while a probation period is running no second deferral may be ordered against the person for an intentional offence. Moreover, one of the conditions is that the defendant must not previously have been convicted of an intentional offence. If the first deferral ended in discontinuance because the probation period passed without incident, there is no conviction and so no legal obstacle to applying it again in a new file. If the first judgment was announced, however, a conviction for an intentional offence has arisen and a second deferral is not possible.
The effect on compensation and other claims #
A deferral order does not bind the civil court. That deferral was ordered in the criminal file does not require the dismissal of a claim for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages arising from the same incident; the civil judge assesses the incident independently. Likewise the order does not by itself remove a disciplinary step or an administrative sanction to be taken by an employer.
On the other hand, since a deferral order is not a judgment of conviction it does not as a rule produce the consequences attached to a conviction, such as dismissal from public service. Because there is no final finding of guilt against the person, the presumption of innocence continues to be protected.
Not to be confused with similar institutions #
Deferral of the announcement of the judgment is not the same thing as suspension of sentence, conciliation or advance payment. In suspension, a judgment of conviction is entered and recorded, and only its enforcement is suspended. Conciliation is the closing of the file at the investigation stage by agreement between the parties and produces no conviction. Advance payment is the non-institution of the public prosecution in certain minor offences upon payment of the amount provided by law.
For the first stage of a criminal investigation and the exercise of the right of defence, see our guide to statements and the right of defence, and for the whole process our criminal law page; to see which stage you are at, you can use the legal roadmap tool.
The five-year treatment and probation measure applied in the offence of drug use is likewise a different institution from the suspension of the pronouncement of the verdict; for how it works see our article on the offence of drug use and probation.
Constitutional review of deferral and the changing practice #
By its judgment of 10 July 2025 (docket 2024/98, decision 2025/149) the Constitutional Court annulled paragraphs five to fourteen of article 231 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which govern deferral; the annulment was due to take effect on 30 September 2026. Before it took effect, those paragraphs were re-enacted by Law No. 7589 (Official Gazette, 31 July 2026).
The new text kept the appeal route and does not require the defendant’s acceptance; it provides that no second deferral may be ordered for an intentional offence during probation, that the damage may be paid off in monthly instalments during the probation period, and that when the judgment is announced up to half of the sentence may be left unenforced. Since the date of the order determines the route of challenge and whether acceptance is required, when a deferral order reaches you it is important to note its date and the route of challenge stated in it and to have it assessed without losing time.
What happens when the probation period ends? #
If the probation period is completed in compliance with the obligations, the judgment whose announcement was deferred is set aside and the case is discontinued. That does not amount to an acquittal, but neither does it produce a conviction: it does not appear on the criminal record and does not as a rule bar public employment or professional licences.
The record is kept in a separate system specific to deferral orders and can be seen only in order to determine whether the person can benefit from the institution in a later investigation. If a new intentional offence is committed during the probation period, the judgment is announced and the two sentences are enforced separately.

