What we do
Calculators Legal guide Legal glossary Frequently asked questions About us Contact

Rent Determination Cases: Conditions, Timing and Outcomes

The five-year rule, the consumer price index cap, when to file, and from which date the rent rises.

Rent Determination Cases: Conditions, Timing and Outcomes — Hasan Hüseyin Uzun Law Office legal guide

In short: Where the rent has fallen far below market value, the route is an action to determine the rent. This guide covers the conditions, the five-year rule, the requirement to serve notice and the equitable reduction.

An action to determine the rent is the claim by which the rent is reset by the court. For the landlord it is the way to bring the rent closer to market value; for the tenant it is the way to resist an excessive demand for an increase. The annual ceiling the law places on rent increases does not apply in this action; the court sets the amount freely.

The difference between the annual increase and the action to determine #

In leases of dwellings and roofed business premises, the rate of increase applied for renewed rental periods cannot exceed the rate of change in the consumer price index by twelve-month averages for the previous rental year. That ceiling applies even if a higher rate is written into the contract. If you want to see the rate for your own contract, you can use our rent increase calculator.

An action to determine the rent falls outside that ceiling. Without being bound by the index, the court sets the amount taking into account the condition of the property and comparable rents. That is why this action is the only real solution for property that has long been occupied at a low rent.

Legal basis: The determination of the rent is governed by Article 344 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098; in tenancies lasting longer than five years the judge determines the rent according to equity.

When can it be brought? #

There are three separate situations:

  • Leases of less than five years: where the parties have set the rent by contract, the rule is to wait for five years to elapse before the action can be brought. If no rate of increase was agreed in the contract, determination can be sought at the end of each year.
  • Leases of more than five years: in each rental year after the fifth, the action can be brought without being bound by the index ceiling. The court sets an equitable amount by weighing the change in the index, the condition of the property and comparable rents together.
  • Leases in foreign currency: the rent cannot be changed until five years have passed; after five years the provisions on excessive difficulty of performance may also come into play.

The notice requirement: the most critical detail #

As important as the outcome of the action is the period from which the increase takes effect. The rule is this: if the action is brought at the latest thirty days before the start of the new rental period, or if within that period the landlord gives written notice that the rent will be increased, the amount set by the court applies from the start of the new period.

If no such notice was given and the action was not brought in time, the amount determined applies only from the following rental year. That is, a year’s difference is lost. Sending the notice through a notary is the safe route as regards proving the date of service.

How does the court set the amount? #

The judge carries out an on-site inspection in the area where the property is situated and obtains a report from a panel of experts. The assessment takes into account:

  • The property’s location, age, heating system, and whether it has a lift and parking
  • Gross and net floor area, the floor it is on, its aspect and its view
  • Current rents of comparable properties in the same building and neighbourhood
  • Lasting improvements the tenant has made to the property
  • The length of the tenancy — a long tenancy is a factor in the tenant’s favour

The equity reduction #

In practice the courts do not award the comparable rent directly. In favour of a tenant of long standing, an equity reduction is applied to the comparable figure. That reduction reflects the fact that the tenant has stayed in the property for a long time and that there is no cost of finding a new tenant. Its size varies with the file and lies in the court’s discretion.

The proceedings and the costs #

The action is brought in the civil court of peace for the place where the property is situated. Since it arises from a tenancy, applying to a mediator before bringing the action is compulsory; an action brought without doing so is dismissed on procedural grounds. Because of the costs of the on-site inspection and the expert examination, the expense of the proceedings is high compared with an ordinary claim for a debt; those costs are taken in advance from the party bringing the action and returned to the successful party.

Depending on how quickly the inspection and expert report are completed, the proceedings usually take one to two years. Throughout that period the tenant continues to pay the old amount. Once the judgment is final, the difference for the past period can be claimed as accrued arrears; the length of the proceedings therefore does not work against the landlord.

The position with business premises #

Leases of roofed business premises are subject to the same regime; but two differences stand out in practice. First, researching comparable rents is harder for business premises: the rental value of a shop on a main street depends less on floor area than on footfall and location. Second, the clientele the tenant has brought to the premises and the investment they have made are taken into account as factors in their favour in the assessment of equity.

For lettings in shopping centres, where the sums are calculated on turnover, the nature of the contract is assessed separately. Some of those contracts are treated not as leases but as mixed contracts not regulated by statute, and are not the subject of an action to determine the rent.

What happens after the judgment? #

Once the judgment is final, the new amount applies from the period determined by reference to the notice or the date of the action. If the tenant does not pay the new amount, the landlord can start enforcement proceedings for default and, where the conditions are met, seek eviction. The amount determined then rises in later years subject to the index ceiling again; that is, a determination judgment does not confer a right to unlimited increases in the years that follow. A fresh action to determine can again be brought after five years.

What can the tenant do? #

The tenant can show that the demand is excessive through comparable tenancy agreements, printouts of advertisements and documents about the property’s shortcomings. Heating problems, damp, the absence of a lift, or the fact that renovations were paid for by the tenant are all factors that pull the amount down. Where the five-year period has not elapsed, dismissal of the action can also be sought.

It should not be confused with eviction claims: an action to determine the rent does not remove the tenant, it only sets the amount. For the routes to eviction see our guide to evicting a tenant, and for the subject as a whole our real estate and tenancy law page.

How is the comparable rent established? #

In an action to determine the rent the judge decides not on the parties’ assertions but on an expert examination. The expert compares the current rents of similar properties in the area where the property is situated. The main criteria used in the comparison are: gross and net floor area, the age of the building, the floor and aspect, whether there is a lift, parking or a gated complex, the heating system, the state of maintenance and the location (proximity to a main road, the metro, schools).

Once the comparable figure is found, the judge does not apply it directly: an equity reduction is made. It is settled practice to set an amount below the comparable figure in favour of a tenant who has lived in the same property for a long time, has paid the rent regularly and has looked after it. For that reason the amount produced by an action to determine usually remains somewhat below the market rent for a new letting.

Does the rent continue to be paid while the action runs? #

Yes — and this is the most critical point on the tenant’s side. That an action to determine has been brought does not suspend the obligation to pay the existing rent. While the action runs the tenant must continue to pay the old amount regularly; otherwise they fall into default and a risk of eviction also arises. Once the judgment is final, the new amount runs back to the rental period in which the action was brought, and the difference can be claimed together with interest. Setting the likely difference aside is therefore a practical precaution for the tenant.

Av. Hasan Hüseyin Uzun
Av. Hasan Hüseyin Uzun
Avukat · Hasan Hüseyin Uzun Avukatlık Bürosu

Frequently asked on this subject

4 questions
Does an action to determine the rent get the tenant evicted?
No. That action concerns only the fixing of the rent; it does not produce eviction. Eviction requires separate grounds and a separate case.
Can I sue before five years have passed?
If a rate of increase has been agreed in the contract, the rule is to wait for the five years to elapse. If the contract contains no provision on the rate of increase, determination can be sought at the end of each rental year. In leases denominated in foreign currency the rent cannot be changed before five years have passed.
From what date does the rent fixed by the court apply?
If the case was brought at least thirty days before the start of the new rental period, or if written notice of an increase was given within that period, it applies from the start of the new period. Otherwise it applies only from the following rental year.
Which rent should I pay while the case runs?
The existing rent continues to be paid until the judgment is final. Falling behind on payment creates a separate risk of eviction for default. Once the judgment is final, the difference for the past period can be claimed as accrued arrears.

This article is for general information; it is not legal advice on your own case. Time limits and their application can vary with the particulars of a file. Let us talk your situation through.

All our services in Real Estate and Tenancy Law Tenant eviction, rent increases and rent determination, collection of unpaid rent, annulment of…

Contact

You can reach the office by phone, by email or through the appointment form. Meetings take place at the office in Bakırköy or by video.

WhatsApp Call